simithmike simithmike

Star Trek: Voyager is a good show.

Star Trek: Voyager is a good show.

Star Trek: Voyager is a good show. Almost as good as the best example of Star Trek, that is, in my opinion, Star Trek: The Next Generation.
Star Treck: Voyager DVD, like other Star Treks, is a science fiction show with a heavy component based on drama. In my opinion, the science fiction elements are just the start engine and the spice used to create a developed stage to show the watcher how human behave in certain situations, like betrayal, love, prejudice, quest for power and many more. Some characters are good, but unfortunately they are only the minority. And the doctor is too hard to believe, despite I think he is the best character in the show.
Overall the episode quality is good, but there are some episodes that drop the quality solidly. Unfortunately they are a good part of the show.
Star Treck: Voyager series isn't the best Star Trek, but it is one that is faithful to its origin. And one that is fun to watch.

 

330,695 views 103 replies +1 Loading…
Reply #26 Top

Quoting Star, reply 17

DS9 was by far the best ST show. It ran for 7 seasons and all of them were good.
Thats just your opinion. In mine the first three seasons were crap.

I quite agree, it wasn't till they meet the jem'hadar till the show really pick up up till then was just petty problems, and more of a soap, and the klingons came back did the shows starts to build some tension

But I like the fact that Gene, didn't allow any personal relationship between the crew, stops things from being a soap

Yet, I would probably like to know more about the what 70 odd years between TOS and TNG, now that would be more intersting.

Reply #27 Top

like how James T. Kirk was not the first captain of the USS enterprice NCC 1701

Pike was.

Reply #28 Top

But I like the fact that Gene, didn't allow any personal relationship between the crew, stops things from being a soap

Well, i guess we didn't see the same seasons; Dax/Worf, Odo/Kira, Bashir/Quark's bar girl, O'Brien/Family... it kept being a soap.

Reply #29 Top

I like all star treks. If star trek is on chances are i will probably watch it. This being playoff season and all however  haven't watched one this week.

Making a hierarchical taxonomy of my favorite series would look like the following

 

TNG- Of course Picard is a bad ass mother@#$ and I like the interactions between Worf and his human counterparts.

TOS - Simply because it's what started it all. Everything in Star trek derives form it.

Voyager - I like voyager over DS9 becasue of the fact that they are on a ship actually moving and exploring (even though they're lost) and meeting new races.

DS9 - loved it again especially for Worf and how he falls in love with that girl (As you can see i dont watch the shows too often)

Enterprise - have watched ONE episode in my entire life, will never watch another one.

 

 

Now if i had to do the same with movies it would go something like this.

1st - Generations

2nd - The Undiscovered Country (as you can tell i like the klingons)

3rd - First Contact

4th - and Ironically the fourth movie - The voyage home

5 - The wrath of Khan

6 - Final Frontier

7 - Search for Spock

8 - TMP

9 - Nemesis

10 - Insurection

 

 

+1 Loading…
Reply #30 Top

I loved Voyager... especially how after year 2 every season finale was related to the Borg in some form or fashion!

 

WE ARE THE BORG~!

Reply #31 Top

http://www.hammacher.com/publish/75698.asp?promo=homepage

 

Best toy ever

Reply #33 Top

Personally DS9 was my fave because of the darker war stuff that it goes into when it finally picks up. That and we actually get to see a Starbase, DS9 itself fight and they were some of the best special effects in star trek.

Voyager was a soap in space pretty much Imo and I never got into it really, and they turned the borg into wimps which I hated, the borg managed to wack 40 fed ships with one cube now all of a sudden a single Intrepid class ship, a light cruiser no less can kick their arses.

Now Enterprise had a few good stories like I thought it was cool how they explained and tied in the fact as to why early Klingons did not have the forehead ridges. But the whole time travel / xindi thing was a big heap of fail.

 

As for the films  Nemesis and first contact were my two fave films. Nemesis because we finally get to see what Enterprise-E can do though I wasn't struck on the whole clone thing and the killing off of a major character.

First contact I loved because it made the borg badass again and It was a part of Picards history that came back to haunt him as it were.

Reply #34 Top

But the only thing I it is wrong with star trek, even though there are so many races, what language do they communicate in? English? I mean come on not all races will be able to speak English, and if you notice the names of the ships, most are either very american (Uss Rosevelt) or the ship class, won't the people of different races complain that they don't get ship names in their honor?

Reply #35 Top

First contact I loved because it made the borg badass again and It was a part of Picards history that came back to haunt him as it were.

I really enjoyed this movie as well.  I remember when I went to the theatre to see the steven segal movie "Executive Decision".  They played the First Contact trailer, I almost shat myself when I saw that cube on a rampage again.  I think this movie came out before Voyager destroyed their character though.

I was never a fan of TOS, I still think the Wrath of Khan was the best movie.


I actually disliked Nemesis.  It was so implausible.  The reman`s are a slave race of the romulan`s.  How were they able to build the Scimitar?  They built this ship in secret did they not?  Where did they hide the massive infrastructure needed to build such a ship?  Where did they develop the advanced tech it used?  Somehow they perfected the tech needed to fire while cloaked?  I couldn`t get past these things.

Reply #36 Top

Quoting NickJames, reply 10






I actually disliked Nemesis.  It was so implausible.  The reman`s are a slave race of the romulan`s.  How were they able to build the Scimitar?  They built this ship in secret did they not?  Where did they hide the massive infrastructure needed to build such a ship?  Where did they develop the advanced tech it used?  Somehow they perfected the tech needed to fire while cloaked?  I couldn`t get past these things.

Agreed 100% on both counts. nemesis was a terrible failure plot wise. Special effects wise it was pretty good and i like the romulans, too bad they get OWNED. What Im also wondering is why the hell they wouldn't send a Warbird after the scimitar. It is my understanding that warbirds are among the most powerful ships in all of star trek. instead they send two romulan bird of preys, small frigates!?!? come on.

Reply #37 Top

Quoting NickJames, reply 10

First contact I loved because it made the borg badass again and It was a part of Picards history that came back to haunt him as it were.
I really enjoyed this movie as well.  I remember when I went to the theatre to see the steven segal movie "Executive Decision".  They played the First Contact trailer, I almost shat myself when I saw that cube on a rampage again.  I think this movie came out before Voyager destroyed their character though.

I was never a fan of TOS, I still think the Wrath of Khan was the best movie.


I actually disliked Nemesis.  It was so implausible.  The reman`s are a slave race of the romulan`s.  How were they able to build the Scimitar?  They built this ship in secret did they not?  Where did they hide the massive infrastructure needed to build such a ship?  Where did they develop the advanced tech it used?  Somehow they perfected the tech needed to fire while cloaked?  I couldn`t get past these things.

 

Thats true though I mainly liked it because we got to see the Enterprise - E in action properly as it were. Previous movies with the ship only had token fights at best.

 

I also have to agree about the warbird thing. If its the Rommies home system shouldn't it be Crawling with their ships?

Warbirds are powerful but not massively. The Sovereign class trumps it hands down in basically every field from weapon firepower to shields and speed. The warbirds biggest advantage is cloaking and I think warbirds have very heavy hull armour. They took a lot more to destroy by the dominion than say a galaxy class did.

Reply #38 Top

Hot chick makes a show not.  Think with brain, not penis...

 

I weep for my gender...

Reply #39 Top

Voyager was awesome...even to the point of being able to put up with Johnny football hero douche Paris. But as for the comic book store guy complaints regards realism, I really think you're doing it wrong. The reality boat pretty much sailed the minute Gene thought "what about a spaceship."

Reply #40 Top

But as for the comic book store guy complaints regards realism, I really think you're doing it wrong.

Star Trek has always tired to retain some semblence of reality.  It`s all imagined, Most of it had a gradual progression of tech in it.  That`s a main reason I liked Star Trek at all.  Nemesis threw that out the window to create a viable enemy.

Reply #41 Top

Quoting Mooster, reply 9
But the only thing I it is wrong with star trek, even though there are so many races, what language do they communicate in? English? I mean come on not all races will be able to speak English
Err, your Avatar doesn't really fit if you don't know that the Starfleet's communicator actually contains an on the fly translator. Otherwise the other species are in fact talking english or when other races talk with their kind, they talk in their language, but we hear it as english, for the viewer's convenience ;).

Quoting Mooster, reply 9
and if you notice the names of the ships, most are either very american (Uss Rosevelt) or the ship class, won't the people of different races complain that they don't get ship names in their honor?
Only Starfleet ships are named like that... have you ever seen Star Trek? ;P

Reply #42 Top

Quoting AshBrewster, reply 12

Warbirds are powerful but not massively. The Sovereign class trumps it hands down in basically every field from weapon firepower to shields and speed.

 

I beg to differ.  ^_^   In one DS9 episode a single Warbird destroys the entire station with a single plasma torpedo before it is even detected, punching through all the armored layers of hull and containment fields protecting the powercore, and they are only saved because O'Brien suddenly can warp through time and warns them.

In another episode 6 of them plus some utterly redundant Cardassian ships destroy 30%(!) of an entire planet's surface in just the initial volley, and according to the episode's script they would vaporize(!) the entire crust within the hour. That would mean that a single Warbird could vaporize the entire crust in a mere 6 hours, which puts the Soveregn to shame in terms of firepower.

 

In other words, the only reason the Enterprise miraculously survives all Romulan encounters is because otherwise the serie would end. I'm still waiting for a new serie called Star Trek Romulus: The Age of Conquest though, which follows a certain ambitious Romulan commander of a Warbird while he expands the Romulan Empire's borders, running into all kind of first contact situations and dealing with them the Romulan way.

Reply #43 Top

But the only thing I it is wrong with star trek, even though there are so many races, what language do they communicate in? English? I mean come on not all races will be able to speak English

This was one of the best parts of Enterprise IMO.  They actually had to try and communicate with aliens without a universal translator.  Enterprise had so much potential.  All they had to do was stick to the basics.  Explore the creation of these tech`s and first contact with the Star Trek races.  Instead, they decided to create new one`s.  This show had so much great content already created to work with.  I know they did use some of it.  First contact with the kligon`s was great.  I think they did the romulan`s too, Not sure.  They killed it by going so far off course witn the Sulabon and Xindi.

Reply #44 Top

Yamato, Horatio, Yamaguchi, Zhukov, Valdemir, Ghandi, Kearsarge, Buran...

 

I'd keep going through the list, but it's too damned fragmented and satellite isn't the best for browsing.  There are hundreds of less than anglo centric named ships without leaving series canon, and that's not even factoring in multicultural icons that have been Americanized by frequent use, like Pegasus or Hercules which are both Greek.  There's nothing American about Enterprise itself, it's an anglo-french word from the middle english period that perfectly fits the role of the ship.  Space exploration is most definitely a complicated, difficult and risky task.

 

A view that they're all named after US icons is pure perception with no basis.

Reply #45 Top

Enterprise was originally a Royal navy ship of the Enterprize class frigate tyoe.frigate class ship in the British royal navy.

Enterprise herself was decommed and broken down in 1784 and served as a prison ship moving prisoners to the Tower of London until 1807 when she was broken up.

 

In 1806 another Enterprize class frigate the HMS Recourse  was renamed to Enterprise in 1806 to replace the original. She was decommed and broken up in 1816.

 

The first USS Enterprise was a sloop of war formerly called the George until her capture in a forts shipyard in 1775.

The first American Navy ship USS Enterprise was a schooner built at Baltimore shipyard in 1799.

Reply #46 Top

I can't stand most of the crews on Voyager!  Enterprise is better imo.

Reply #47 Top

Quoting Spooky, reply 7

Quoting Zyxpsilon, reply 2Pike was.Nope, Ropert April.

Hold it, isn't Christopher Pike in the first Cage episode? End then, got re-filmed to integrate Kirk?

If you're talkin' animated series... maybe. But a Carey's novel isn't a genuine original TeeVee show.

Reply #48 Top

Quoting psychoak, reply 19

A view that they're all named after US icons is pure perception with no basis.

 

Although I agree with your previous arguments I must beg to differ on this one.

In The Voyage Home Scotty and McCoy meet the chief engineer of which ship??? The American USS Enterprise Aircraft Carrier.

It's no mistake or coincidence that the Main ship of the series (an American series) is named after the most famous and recognizable american warship of all time.

Reply #49 Top

Quoting Zyxpsilon, reply 22
Hold it, isn't Christopher Pike in the first Cage episode? End then, got re-filmed to integrate Kirk?

If you're talkin' animated series... maybe. But a Carey's novel isn't a genuine original TeeVee show.
Yes, Christopher Pike was in the first episode. However, when Roddenberry first submitted his proposal for the TV show, his name for the captain was "Robert T. April". The animated series picked up on that and made it canon. However, you are right, it is debateable if April is actually part of the continuity or not :)

Reply #50 Top

if i had to decide on priority it would be in this form:

1. TNG

2. DS9

3. Voyager

4. Enterprise

5. TOS

 

to like TOS even a bit i was probably born 20 years too late :D