Oh I can't resist this invitation...
It's the hypocrisy that kills me, plephart, not the trash talkin'. Sure we're all hypocrites, but yours is a kind that's very damaging. I'll try to explain, which will also cover how I developed distaste for MWC.
You are completely right on this count Kit. The simple emotional intent of my words was that GROSS is an empire that thrives on easier difficulties and a cheesy strategy. I see no name calling there, just an opinion that I hold about your empire...take it personally if you must, but there is no more personal attack there than for your own leader Pontius to call our empire whiners. I take no personal offense at that, its just part of the trashtalkin that goes on.
End of quote
To indicate that an empire thrives on easier difficulty settings and a cheesy strategy is not in itself an emotional intent. It is based on an emotional intent. I would guess that emotion is concern. Concern that G.R.O.S.S. is damaging the Metaverse with an agreed upon tactic. This is not where the hypocrisy lies. Let me point it out:
"I see no name calling there, just an opinion that I hold about your empire..."
Further on you state:
"Trashtalkin is part of the game."
You're implying that your statistics, in which you also state "Read it and weap pirates, step up the difficulty or be mocked", was trashtalkin, correct? And we have no need to quibble on the difference between name calling and trashtalkin, correct? So which is it, plephart? Are you or are you not name calling / trashtalkin? To respond that you do or don't is not the point. You clearly indicate as you backpedal that you don't name call. BUT you admit that you trashtalk. This is hypocrisy. This is misleading. This is a danger to young impressionable minds.
Here's the connection that pisses me off about MWC. A sampling from MWC members:
axels2000 - "MWC stands for noble cause and fair game."
A commendable theme to start with.
surther - "You see here in the Midwest we are raised on values. We respect our neighbors and love our enemies."
This implies that other regions are not raised on values.
plephart - "if you want some helpful tips on how to score in this great game, join up and come into our members only chatroom. We'll get ya up to speed quick! Our only requirements are twofold, have some connection to the Midwestern US of A and despise the evil empire G.R.O.S.S."
So the theme is exclusively the American Midwest now. OK, that's fine.
surther - "We welcome Midwesterners from around the world as well as those from the Midwest. Those of you in the Ukraine or Brazil or anywhere who are in the glorious farm belts and wheatlands come join our mighty empire."
Except that it's more now.
surther - "Our small empire is a cross section of the good old USA and shows why we as a nation are so strong. We set our goals and we stick to it and the Midwest provides the grain and the muscle that makes us strong."
No, sorry, it's just the American Midwest again.
axels2000 - "On a different topic: let me re-emphasize, MWC is achievment of Australia, Asia, South America, Northern America and Europe. Of all good people with the mindset of value-added workers/players. We do not segregate on territorial principles."
Oops again. We're back to including all of the privileged folks who have values.
plephart - "Alls fair in love and war and to finish off my thread of common sayings, no blood, no foul!"
And which noble cause does this reflect?
Yes, I'm pulling your quotes from many sources, but this is how I developed distaste for MWC. All of the empires have struggled to develop a theme that works for them. Y'all struggled. That's fine, except that your claim on values has an exclusionary undertone. You're promoting this theme as the "good guys" and kids may actually believe that they really are better than other regions, cultures, etc. It's one thing to be proud of your heritage. It's another to look down on others without even acknowledging your hubris. Chalk it up to role-playing if you like, but I have an uneasy suspicion it goes well beyond role-playing for some MWC members.
Prove me wrong! I want nothing more than to have my fellow Americans show the world that, despite the press, they're actually wonderfully open-minded folks.