oddity
I recently bought this game and I'm impressed with the game mechanics and sheer scope of play.
However the game balance seems a little... skewed.
I have tried all three races, and though advent take a hurting early on I played in a game as them once and came upon an interesting scenario.
I had 2 capital ships just cruising through the planets looking for a new colony to forge, my main fleet was off in another sector.
I took these 2 because they had been my main ships starting out... a halcyon carrier and a progenator mothership. Nothing else. They were level 9 and level 8 respectively.
Suddenly they run into a moderate sized fleet consisting of 2 level 6 and a level 7 capital ship combined with 3 cruiser carriers and about 30 other frigates.
I'm about to hightail it out of there when I noticed something interesting. After a single pass all of my opponents strike craft disappeared. (I usually set an equal ratio of bombers and fighters after mid game) My computer opponent was terran. I looked at the target for my bombers and noticed I had taken a nice chunk of shield so I thought maybe I could take down one of his capital ships before mine got destroyed and I figured I would be able to run if things got dicey. (Yes, there were flak frigates with the fleet)
So I stayed getting ready to split on a moments notice. I needn't have bothered. I wiped out every single ship and they didn't even get past my shields. Since the flak frigates go after fighters before targeting bombers, they weren't really even an issue. I just watched amazed as the first capital ship went down without even 10% of my shields being gone. I didn't use any fancy maneuvering, I duked it out toe to toe. Sure I had a lvl 9 and a lvl 8 vs a lvl 7 and 2 lvl 6, but even so that's ridiculous... 2 capital ships wiping out 3 so handily that they also obliterated 30 frigates without even having their shields punched through? I then looked around these forums and saw people touting phase missles as uber and wonderful...
So I looked at the vas tech tree.
Phase missles are only capable of doing 30% phase damage. That makes upgrading phase missles worse than useless! Sure shooting through shields sounds great you get to damage the hull directly. This is good right? WRONG (maybe Im pointing out something someone has already stated so forgive me if I'm repeating). When you fire at the shield, you shoot only at the shield. So at this period of time only the shield regeneration kicks in. During that time the hull regen is inactive. Since the phase is only 30%, you are guaranteed to deplete the shields anyways before taking out the ship. This means that instead of having a time where only the shield regen is active, both shield and hull regen are always active thus actually depleting the damage you deal- unless I'm wrong and the phase missle does 100% to shields and then another 30% to hull and not 70% to shield and 30% to hull, you're actually getting decreased damage and judging from what Ive seen it actually IS 70/30. It is rather difficult to judge tho since everything with phase missles gets eaten rather quickly. Can someone tell me for sure? If it's 70/30 that portion of the tech tree is absolutely worthless even WITH the damage upgrade later on.