Understood, though in my opinion the underline on all of them isn't necessary because if it's pinned but not running then it'll appear as just an icon with no text and much smaller width, so it would be obvious that it's not running.
To me the most important thing to know is which app is in focus, but ideally in a clean, obvious but undistracting way. I think having the Windows 10 style underline appearing *only* on the app in focus would make it perfect. My two cents.