I am 42 years old and have been playing computer games since I was 7 years old whem my father used a CP500 with green phosphor monitor and taught me the first command lines in BASIC, since then it was love at first sight, and I hope to see in VGM the opportunity to portray some drafts of that time witch, with the passage of time, were only in memory.

Among other engines like Game Maker, Construct, Unity and Unreal, I hope to see a more artistic and less codified way to put my ideas into practice...

I look forward to the launch !!!

Will it be possible to code something complex or even rewrite the whole engine like in Maker series?

Quoting ScottTykoski,

reply 3

chengsta2: I don't know if we're going to specifically have a 'Tactical RPG' Genre to pick from, there will be several Gameplay Rules that should get you close.

BadJackDaniels: Agreed! As much as we all love coding, we don't want it to be this hurdle players have to overcome to enjoy making games. While more limited than code-heavy engines, we're hoping that VGM lets them get creative and make something they're proud of with as little frustration as possible. Making games should feel like a game in itself!

We look forward to your feedback once the Founders Build goes out! 

As another tactical RPG fan, I am hoping we can eventually get really close. I signed up for the founders program today, because it seems a low risk for a potentially high reward. Anyway, I at some point I hope we can create a stealth adventure game like Metal Gear for the NES, along with traditional turn based RPGs (Final Fantasy I, Dragon Warrior/Quest 3/4, hell even Pokemon) instead of just Zelda clones. 

One question, is about enemy AI, how much of it will be in the game and how much control will we have over it?

I appreciate your honesty, and understand why you would want to avoid competing with Mario Maker (The recent Nintendo direct for Mario Maker 2 make it look like it will be really good, and a beast to compete with), or RPG maker. However, maybe your niche could be genre mixing, like an RPG but if your party runs into a monster on the overhead screen maybe it could shift to a traditional turn based RPG menu combat screen, or a tactical RPG combat screen or a Mega Man boss battle, or a Metroidvania ministage, or maybe not. Anyway I wish you the best of luck.

One thing I hope we can see in the side scrolling shooters are Blackthorne like rules (Assassin Creed Chronicles would be a modern similar instance), instead of just Mega Man or Contra/Super-C rules.

I really hope we can easily build RTS civ like game. got so many idea, cant wait to try them.

So a few things in this mindset that I'd really like to see:

Cross genres. Think Zelda 2 The Adventure of link having an overworld that is akin to the top-down adventure style of Zelda 1 or 3, but then you go into dungeon/combat areas that are side scrolling. You mention this somewhat above, but genre mixing would be SUPER cool. (As mentioned, Actraiser is still one of the most awesome things on the SNES)

Genre wishes:

• Open Map side-scrollers: Think Metroid, Castlevania: SOTN, etc. Honestly I think that just becomes if you can implement an inventory system in your side-scroller genre and how large maps can be.
• Mega Man style platformers: this is basically your standard platformer stuff, but with the ability to revisit levels and set up boss weaknesses from powerups you obtained
• If not necessarily all RPGs, what about action-RPGs? There is nothing out there right now that'd let you make Terranigma and/or Illusion of Gaia right now.
  • Your top-down adventure genre seems to cover most of the movement stuff, just adding an inventory and the ability to level up to that would accomplish this.
  • (I'd also die for a way to make tactical RPGs as already mentioned, but not like most people thing. While FFT-style would be great, I want to make a Shining Force style game with cool battle scenes and top-down perspective/transitions)
• A lot of people mentioned similar ideas above, but some kind of tactical/strategy game would be cool. Something like Sim City, Civ, or even something more small scale like Into the Breach? (This one's probably hard because of how much custom logic you'd have to have per enemy, I guess?). This would be needed to make Actraiser's strategy layer. Doesn't have to be turnbased, could be real time. 
• Full-blown adventure game? Like Kings Quest/Monkey Island style? Not sure how easy that can be adapted.
• Probably my least desired genre, but still cool: Old School vertical/horizontal Shooters (1942, Gradius, etc) would be great, too.

Edit: 

One other thought, what about a collectible card game genre? Maybe not something too complex, but you could take any of your hero/monster icons, slap them on a card, and give them cost/attack/defense values (and maybe some kind of simple skills?). I don't know of anything like that out there, and that could be a lot of fun for people to mess with. Doesn't necessarily have to be Magic the Gathering style, as there are a ton of solo CCGs out there now.

I'm really excited to see where VGM goes, as I've messed with GameDev a few times but still see big value in alternatives:

• Could never get into my very costly GameMaker Studio 2 license because simple things (Making a title screen) couldn't be done with their drag and drop system.
• I've messed with (and love) GDevelop 5 due to how simple it makes things, even though it still requires a bit more knowledge (compiling, event logic, etc). Actually made a "game" (more like demo) with it that was decent enough that people want to use it as a tutorial for using GD.
  • However, my young nephew (who is also really interested in gamedev, and is the one who reignited my own attempts) isn't able to wrap his head around GDevelop. Looking at VGM it seems like it might be the perfect fit for him (and even me), and would allow us to work on stuff together.

That said, if this huge post doesn't already indicate it, you can likely expect me to throw tons of suggestions/feedback out of the alpha when I can.

Thanks for the quick reply. As mentioned, super excited to mess around with VGM, so seeing you already thinking about future enhancements is great.

Yes, this sounds near of perfect. Even if the scene transition using a Gateway Gizmo isn't "Scroll the camera right/left to the new scene" akin to a Metroid, even a fadeout/fade in gets you 99% of the way there in a platformer. 

Although I suppose if you allow for maps that are big enough, you could get to Castlevania 2 style where the main map is moderately huge with no transitions, but then each "Dungeon" area or shop has a distinct transition to a smaller map.

(Simon's Quest overworld map: https://nesmaps.com/maps/Castlevania2/Castlevania2CompleteMapB.png)

Or maybe if the transition is fast enough (no fade out, almost instant cut), you could make it work by stringing together a bunch of maps and having the "Town" areas just be where the outside area stops scrolling, then you cut to the town area as you pass the threshhold?

Obviously, you may already have all of this or are already planning on other items like you mentioned above, so I don't want to bog you down too much with stuff while you're working hard to get the alpha ready.

Yeah, an equipment system is really useful for any genre, and could easily be used for powerups and such in genres you already have?

(e.g. You could use an equipment system for Gradius for the powerups, basically. Or in a platformer, your equipment system lets you store extra powerups you get in the world map, like Super Mario Brothers 3, or Super Mario 3D World, etc. Equipment is mandatory for Metroid style games just from a weapon select perspective, I think? Definitely required for Mega Man style games.)

That said, the inverse could also be true, if you just have a pure power-up style system currently, that might be easily adapted into an equipment system depending on how it lets you tweak it?

Also, to clarify/avoid hurt feelings from anyone: I listed scrolling shooter as least desired genre because I have no good ideas around one and it is lowest on my personal priority list.  

I'm excited to see and play what others make out of it, and will be happy to poke around in it as far as testing.

Just curious if there will be any kind of sprite editor, maybe something as simply as changing the colors by having the ability to paint the pixels.

A full sprite editor might be harder for folks that aren't artistically inclined, but I get the demand for it.

Not sure if it'd be easier for you and the rest of your team, Scott (please tell me you have a team), but an easy way to allow more freedom is a "character remixer" of some kind. Let you swap the heads/arms/legs/torso from each hero/sprite you've already included, and a way to recolor them. Again, could totally be way more complex to build, but thought I might throw the idea on the idea pile.

I think it'd be cool if there was a genre for Tower Defense Games. I love the Defense Grid games and just found out about Siege of Centauri!  

So two questions:
Do you think it will have pathfinding?

I think I saw a screenshot that showed conditionals, but I can't find one now.  Will it have conditional statements?  I seem to think I saw a rule block that was for the equivalent of If Statements?

Thanks and I'm really excited to start making!

No, I had seen that one.  I appreciate the help though.  I thought I saw one somewhere else that showed a block that said, "IF This...Then"  or something to that effect.  Edit: Ahh. Rereading my post, you might mean pathfinding.  I updated my post so that part is clearer just in case.

If you were referring to pathfinding, I don't think movement would necessarily mean pathfinding, would it? For instance, movement could be predefined or rule-based.  But pathfinding finds the shortest route from A to B with specific requirements in place.  (Think of a Tower Defense game. If a tower is placed here or here - pathfinding will recalculate the path for enemies to take...) I'm curious about this because Construct 3 has it, but it is very processor intensive. 

To expand on the Mario Maker simplicity, the new Mario Maker 2 trailer shows that you can have blocks/enemies/etc where you draw their path in edit mode, then they move in those directions/path when you trigger then while playing. 

Something similar might be viable for tower defense (as long as you're doing classic tower defense where enemies have hard set paths).