Me not getting mageslayer had nothing to do with the loss. If I remember right I think we lost their portal twice? Once because we wanted to kill Rawrrr so bad that we let mcshane get the portal and didn't even kill rawrrrr. I think that was the biggest fail of the game.

ya... like I said, I did a whole commentary of it.. but lost it >.<  Haven't started another due to schoolwork, and then I have military duty all fri-sunday, and then a bit more schoolwork.  Soo.. I should have a commentary up next weekish so people can see what it might be like and if it's good / bad. 

My comments from the game:  Soccer got some clutch interrupts with penitence on my shamblers and mulch w/e.  Two resulted in a kill, another resulted in a sigil that I shouldn't have had to use.  Ridiculous that he interrupted a .5 sec cast more than once, and a .1 sec cast for mulch in the same game.

QoT power isn't entirely shown in this game, but taking the full damage of beast and oak + pen and spirits long enough that mcshane was able to turn fully capped flag over to us was pretty awesome.

Cow missed at least 3 kills because he used his grasp as damage and didn't save it for an interrupt, allowing a port out from an otherwise sure kill.  Also, I died once because I didn't port out when both stuns were on cd.

They lost the portal the first time because mcshane drew a double port to defend one of their portals, then he ran out, ported down, and reclaimed our portal.

Cow kept trying to run around after we reacquired our portal for the 2nd time, attempting to use j-treads (coupled w/ innerbeast) to force a port to one portal, then running over to the other.  I highlighted that it was completely ineffective, as I was able to run to the other portal with enough time to prevent it from turning yellow even without any speed items.

But of course, none of my awesome comments were included because fucking fraps deleted the 3 gb file shortly after creation.  boo.

I think I'm going to try and find a shorter replay that I've saved and use that.  A 48 minute replay isn't really the best to test the waters with.

I took some time and made some commentary on a meh game with me and a few pugs vs pugs.  We'll see if I get around to compiling it and posting it soon.  I think my ideas will help spur you more creative folk on to making better ones.  I DREAM of getting something posted by the end of next week.  At any rate, it was just an 11 min game, so I found it much easier to compile.  Good testing ground.  Will have to try out fraps and see if I dig the quality any more. 

I'm kind of excited about this.  I feel like I might be doing the replays a little too slow.  In demigod, nothing important can happen for a few minutes, but then everything goes crazy (in the game I reviewed, there was a kill at 1:05, 1:39, 3:05, 3:13, 3:30, 4:14, 6:22... and quite a bit more).  I found myself slowing things down ALOT to cover all of the action and trying to zoom in, etc.  Anyway, its ok a for a first attempt imo.  It takes quite a bit of time to provide decent commentary on a replay (I spent 3 hours and am not done on a 13 min game).

Anyway, here were my steps:

1st time setup - find something to record games - testing in xfire - xfire does great at low rez and a little chop at high.  After testing all settings, I chose to go with low rez.  Then you have to configure your mic, find the hot keys, etc, and then you can record your first game.

After first time setup, here's what I had to do:

• Watch the replay and mark the times of interesting events.  I simply counted any kills so I knew the exact time I'd want to slow down.
• Pay attention to other noteworthy things.  Is a reg spamming a specific player with snipe (is that good/dumb?), etc
• Grab the stats of all of the players involved in the game (I choose who they picked, current rank (today) and win %).  That gives a decent idea of the skill level.  
• Create a screen to open with that shows those players stats (see screen below)... I just setup this up quick in paint - which has no way to align the text exactly. 
• Then, start recording.  I initially missed a few spots I needed to slow down as I was blabbing away about this and that
• If you screw up and miss positioning the camera on an important point, just stop.  End the replay, FF to whereever you need to be, then record again.  You can edit it

Remaining steps before I publish this poo:

• Add a voice over to my title page (shown below)
• Edit the final version of the video to cut out any overlapping crap (where I stopped and restarted)
• Edit dumb ass audio where I sound like a tardo (I probably won't do this)
• Compile and compress the final version
• Upload somewhere

Cool stuff to do:  If we could come up with a simple intro that we call could use, that would be great.  Think like a 15 second opener to all of our commentary set to good music, etc. 

And there you have it. 

[URL=http://img191.imageshack.us/i/loadscreenformatch.png/][/URL]

man i'm so excited about the replay commentaries! I hope it works out well! And we can post them in an orderly fashion on youtube as well! That will advertise the game so much and revive the game. The reason I bought the game was because I saw a replay on youtube from frogboy playing fire tb with his teamspeak voice , and thought this game looks awesome !

When you say rendering - are you are talking about compressing the video or what exactly?  I was thinking about trying fraps to compare quality, etc, but I'm curious when you crashed. 

Yeah - that's cool stuff.  I really like some of the sc2 commentaries, but those are typically done with 2 people - I'm not sure how we could pull that off though with a replay.  I know we could live broadcast a game, but not sure about recording it at the same time... if you could have the commentary recorded along with it... lots of stuff to sort out. 

Gotcha - I figured it must have been using a separate program outside of fraps, but didn't know for sure... I'd really rather not record any commentary and video and have the vid capture crash out on me and corrupt the video... glad to hear that's not the case.

There's a little bit of a limitation I bumped into using xfire.  When recording and doing commentary, you appear to have exactly 2 choices.  You can either record the in game sounds or record your commentary.  Obviously, I chose the latter, but I'm not all that excited about dropping the in game sound to nothing. Is this a constraint in fraps, rawrrr?  Can you record both yourself and the in game audio - or do you have to pick 1 or the other?

right on - good luck with the upload.  Looking forward to seeing a link appear

nah it didn't give too much trouble.. just realized after I finished that game sound was a little low.  It's present.. just low.  I'll get it fixed in the next one.  As it is, part 1 is finished!  Part 2 should take another 2 hours, and part 3 should be like 30 minutes.  Ideally.  In the meantime, I'm looking for another replay in my list of saves.

k sweeeet.

Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hqp3vnLD1BM

Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ib0d46r8qE

Part 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5ktXj7aESA

feedback appreciated.  Also, I have about 12 decent replays saved.  Looking for feedback on which one to try another replay on next week.  All include me playing qot >.>

reg / sed / qot vs ere / oak / reg - all on vent (except the sed on my team)

Rook / Sed / QoT vs Ere / UB / Reg - Mostly pugs.. wip is reg.  Very.. unusual game.  Hilarious tho.

QoT / Reg vs Oak / TB - Me, Defender, Soccer, Teseer respectively

QoT / UB vs UB / Occ - 4Nana, 1Nana vs Red-One, Green-One

Those are probably the highlights.. don't know what people want to see tho.  Halp!

No! I played horrible that game zen:)

oh shit - my favorite comment is - "they could pull 6 kills out of their ass"  lolz.

funny shit. 

also "zen_god - lost to him because of some bullshit" in the demigod 2v2 tournament.  Hah.  Full of fun.  Good job rawrrr!

Hey - keep looking for good games for reviews.  We still have some time before the tourney starts up.

I'm compiling my first commentary now and going to sleep.  I used xfire and am compiling in adobe premier.  I also noticed that I'm missing 1 whole minute from the game (lost a video somewhere on along the line).  At any rate, its a good test to get ready for our tourney.  If things work out ok, I'll be posting that tomorrow at some point on youtube.  Please check it out.  I think we might find that a good balance between the way rawrrr did things and how I did things will make for a good commentary system.

On my wish list - I would love for someone to throw together some sort of common intro for us to use at the start of our matches.  I think I had a good idea showing the win % and ladder rank of folks (but I won't be implementing the commentary I wanted for this one over that title page (where I show the win % - I wanted to talk through each players playstyle and so on).  Anyway, the overall game I picked it just a scrub, somewhat low level game, but I think I had quite a few good points, especially with my slowing down and zooming in on some of that action points. 

looking forward too see your approach:)