Come on this has already been discussed at length, the root almost all the problems is the game is simulated by all players.

Look up why but this is the reason we have peer to peer and that the host client configuration would not fix much the game would still run at the highest ping between players (actually its worse) and almost the same bandwith would be required.

Because the engine is simulated the game is able to look better and feel more 'realistic' than LOL and HON.

I do think that more gpg staff should be put on fixing up the bugs though (im shure the mods for fixes could be cobined and intergrated in 2 days (followed by a month of testing but still).

If I'm playing a game which is lagging because of another player's connection that is the developer's poor design choice, end of story.  Can't keep blaming the players when most players aren't at fault.

And if the netcode in this game is so great all of a sudden, why isn't everybody playing 5 vs 5s?  Everyone is still ducking this question.

Rofl Go frogboy man. Please don't become discouraged though. These people hardly represet how people online feel. All the problems I feel are player made at this point. Forced Desyncs, disconnects (ragequits) and other things. These happen every game. I have to agree that GPG is a slow patcher but instead of releasing buggy patches they release them perfectly the first time which is a first in most games. I play WoW and played EvE and their patches for a day or so just maul the game's connectivity while this isn't the same with Demigod. I remember one week on EvE where i couldn't even go online for a week because there was an error.

People need to be patient. You may be the costumer but certaintly almost aren't always right. Expecially when you blame the developers for MAKING you (massive lol at that) play such a horrible of a game.

"Gnomechomp, please make sure you never buy anything I work on ever again. Seriously. "

Don't worry, I already made that decision roughly April 09.

"People with slower internet connecttions REGARDLESS of how great the netcode is aren't going to be able to play these games."

Again totally missing the point.  Its not whether people with poor connections can play the game well or not, its whether their poor connections are breaking the game for other players with perfectly adequate connections.  Wouldn't happen in a client/server game, like HoN or LoL.  Only happens in P2P, where every players performance is instantly brought down to whichever player has the crappest machine/connection.

You are doing game designing at college, why does that not surprise me?

This is silly.  You guys are all welcome to your opinions on whether P2P or Client/Server is superior, but blanket statements like "Demigod will never be good because it is p2p" is a giant load. I only need to point to this games closest sibling, Supreme Commander, to rule out that whole line of thinking.

These techs both have pros and cons, trade offs and limitations.  RTS games have traditionally used p2p systems for a lot of reasons that, when you compare the technologies, p2p is a natural fit for the genre.

Demigod being p2p means that all players always see the same thing on screen.  This has good aspects (no warping or client side hacks) and bad (all players limited by the slowest speed, reconnecting is basically impossible).   When I'm playing RTS, syncing is a good thing for me.  It means I know what I see is always what's really happening.  How often does that go out the window in a FPS?  "I swear I shot that guy right in the head!"  No, you didn't, on his screen he had already moved. 

Right now the biggest problem with Demigod and its P2P system is upload bandwidth.  That is, many people with fast connections don't realize their upstream is shit.  Being p2p, you need to be able to send game state data as fast as you can receive it.  That's why larger games get worse because people are hitting the ceiling on those tiny upstream allocations their isps sell. Even worse, if you're sharing your bandwidth with anybody else in the house/dorm, it only takes 1 p2p/torrent app to swallow what little upstream you had to begin with.

Yeah, p2p certainly isn't perfect, but there is a reason it's popular with this genre.

"but there is a reason it's popular with this genre."

The genre being RTS? Demigod isn't an RTS.  The difference being in DG you are supposed to have more players.

"I only need to point to this games closest sibling, Supreme Commander, to rule out that whole line of thinking."

Bad analogy, people don't play SupCom any higher than 3 vs 3. 

I'm not arguing that P2P is always a no-go, only that it is a terrible idea for a game supposed to have more than 6 players.  Demigod usually falls flat on its face every time you start a game with 8 players or more.

Pretty much EVERY game in HoN or LoL is 10 player and works perfectly.

I only said P2P was 1 of things holding DG back, the others being a total lack of multiplayer options and the fact the dev team doesn't give a damn about this game/doesn't talk to the publisher.

All I have to say is I see nut sweat on Xaviorsfist's chin. And this game might of sold alot of copies but I also know alot of people who put this game on the "Fuck I wish I would spent all that money on rubbing alchohol and killed myself instead" List.

What I dont understand is people conceding as the giants attack their citadel. I mean is waiting the couple of minutes really that hard? I mean just sit there and watch the rythm of the giants attack. Its quite soothing really

Oh and Supreme Commander was a Peer to Peer game and it was fine. To be honest its just the way the game is. Client server doesnt solve all your problems it only solves one. We still have to get rid of the WoW players

Thats because its shit 4v4 and the gaming code is soo that bad that it lags almost instantly with processing all the input while at the same time saving all your queues etc.

Also no-one on Supreme Commander is that patient

What?  I haven't played SupCom in many moons but I remember 4v4 on Seytons being very popular and working quite well.