Quoting ShadowMaiden,
Your personal or professional opinion? lern2qualify kthnx
Whoa there turbo. I didn't say Eve sucks, just that it's silly. For arguments sake I'll give you the main reason I said that..
The currency system is broken.
It's really easy to abuse the system. Strangely enough, it seems that CCP encourages it as they don't crack down on the infinite macro miners or isk bears who sell constantly on various websites (including Ebay). I have also caught a few GM that have separate accounts and sell to themselves. If they're not doing that.. they're just giving out money for no reason, invalidating having currency in the first place.
I haven't even gotten to the strange cult-like corporations you can join, how you never leave your ship (but for some reason can customize every detail of your chars appearance), not to mention the general sense of all-encompassing boredom that comes over me when I play it for longer than 5 minutes.
That only scratches the surface, but it's pretty much summed up.